The “This Too Shall Pass” Bible Verse & Other Non-Bible-Verses

80

By japtaker

There are a good number of common phrases and sayings in use today that people mistakenly attribute to the Bible. I will discuss four of the major ones, including the “this too shall pass Bible verse”. More important, I think, than knowing where these quotes actually came from, is knowing that they did not come from the Bible. The reason for this is clear: each of these common sayings expresses something which falls far short of the true depth of spiritual wisdom in the Bible. Thus, in popular thought, the Bible becomes considerably more shallow than it actually is.

This Too Shall Pass “Bible Verse”

I was quite surprised when I found out that many, many people apparently think that the saying, “this too shall pass”, is a Bible verse. It certainly does not come from the Bible. It seems to come from the Sufis: Muslim mystics. The saying certainly does express a considerable amount of wisdom, along the lines of Heraclitus, saying that “all is flux”. But while the Bible consistently acknowledges the transience of things on our plane, it also consistently sets this transience in stark juxtaposition to the Eternal. Our source of comfort in difficult times should be the Eternal, not the awareness of transience, as “this too shall pass” seems to suggest.

God Helps Those Who Help Themselves "Bible Verse"

This saying came from Algernon Sydney, and was later used by Benjamin Franklin. Although it certainly may sound good, it also runs contrary to a lot of actual Biblical wisdom that expresses a different concept: God helps people regardless of anything they may or may not have done to help themselves. In fact, according to one line of thinking, it is impossible for a person to “help themselves”, as all good things (even things like faith, virtue, and effort) come as free gifts from God alone. They are not earned.

Cleanliness is Next to Godliness "Bible Verse"

Forms of this idea can be found in some ancient Jewish writings (not the Bible), Francis Bacon, and John Wesley. But there is no bible verse even remotely similar to this phrase. Furthermore, scientific studies have repeatedly failed to demonstrate any statistically significant correlation between cleanliness and godliness.

Money is the Root of All Evil "Bible Verse"

This quote, unlike the others in this article, is a misquotation of an actual bible verse. 1 Timothy 6:10 reads, “For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evils.” There is a great deal of difference between money itself causing evil, and the love of money causing evil. The first formulation makes the Bible’s ethics sound absurdly simplistic. Money, being an inert thing, can not cause evil any more than rocks can cause evil. The real culprit, as the actual Bible verse makes clear, is the excessive desire for wealth. And even this unbalanced craving is not a cause of “all evil”, but of “all kinds of evil”. This makes more sense as well. There are kinds of evil that are clearly not caused by greed, but there are also all kinds of evil that are caused by greed.

If you're enjoying my writing in this article, please take a moment to look at some of my short poems: click here. This opens in a new window, so you won't lose the article you're currently reading.

Conclusion

I’ll leave my inquiry with only those four sayings, because they are widely used, very often mistaken for Bible quotes, and fall wide of anything actually said by the Bible. Thus, they significantly distort the popular conception of the Bible.

Comments

graceomalley profile image

graceomalley Level 4 Commenter 15 months ago

Someone once told me "Neither a borrower nor a lender be" was in the bible. I'm not sure she beleived me when i told her that quote is from Hamlet :)

japtaker profile image

japtaker Hub Author 15 months ago

Maybe anything written in quaint English sounds like the Bible to people? Thus the "shall" in "this too shall pass" throws people off?

graceomalley profile image

graceomalley Level 4 Commenter 15 months ago

I think you are onto something there.

Twilight Lawns profile image

Twilight Lawns Level 7 Commenter 14 months ago

I really do love your hubs, my friend. you speak sense, but don't preach. You are brief and to the point and you touch on matters that are relevant.

I was fascinated to discover that "This too shall come to pass" originated with the Sufis. A branch of Islam which I have always found fascinating, mystical and poetic... until I looked into the rigours that go along with the philosophy.

japtaker profile image

japtaker Hub Author 14 months ago

Thank you, twilight! I too, have always found the Sufis fascinating, although I'll admit that I haven't yet looked into the rigors of their philosophy. Feel free to share what you know about it right here in the comments if you like :)

Twilight Lawns profile image

Twilight Lawns Level 7 Commenter 14 months ago

Well, first, let me say I'm selfish and like the creature comforts. OK?

Sufis have a leader to whom they look for guidance and follow around. They also give up all worldly goods and carry a bowl for alms; mainly food and rely in the generosity of others. Then with a bit of luck and a lot of prayer and effort and learning, perhaps become a master themselves.

I know this is simplistic to the extreme, and someone who "knows all about Sufism" will come and tell me I know nothing... I suppose I do, but when I learned these basic bits, I thought, the whirling Dervish business and the mysticism and trance like states may be fun, but "in the world and of it" are my ideas of following a true path

tlmcgaa70 profile image

tlmcgaa70 Level 6 Commenter 7 months ago

ironically, my mother and i were just talking about this very thing, and i considered writing a hub on it...alas you beat me to it. at least it is written. well done. i told mom if cleanliness WAS next to Godliness...i am sure GOD would have meant internal cleanliness, as HE always was more concerned with a persons spiritual state rather than how he looked on the outside.

sonfollowers profile image

sonfollowers Level 3 Commenter 7 months ago

Good stuff, my friend. I like your writing style. I'm looking forward to reading more of your work. See you around.

6 months ago

excellence. A real truth seeker.

Jezelangel profile image

Jezelangel 6 months ago

Good...very useful for my research studies..Keep on writing!

sallysunshine 6 weeks ago

I am so happy that I am solid in Christ as "this too shall pass" is extreme comfort to me as I know GOD has a plan that makes "everything ALL right" and I say this because I believe it! Do not be too critical of believers that do not express themselves exactly as you do.....that is how you lose them!

gracefaith profile image

gracefaith Level 1 Commenter 5 weeks ago

Haha, fantastic idea for a hub! I hate the 'this too shall pass' nonsense. It may well not while we are on Earth- whatever it is! :P

Happy hubbing :)

Chris 4 weeks ago

Thus was very helpful. I will pay this forward.

Stephen 2 days ago

What one must understand is that these people GET THEM from the bible, and toy with the words and rephrase them, claiming them as their own. Thomas Jefferson did the same thing as did Alexander Pope and Thomas Wolfe. The ideas came from there. And if not, it is amazing that people are near paraphrasing something written long before their existence.

Stephen 2 days ago

An adequate question for the believer to ask, though, is how biblical is the comfort found in the reminder that "This too shall pass." Really we should be focusing on the promise of what awaits us who believe. Romans 5 reminds the believer that suffering produces hope for the kingdom of God; if we simply take heart in the temporary end of a given earthly trial, we are finding comfort in the wrong thing. I have found in reading both stories in mythhology, and even fairy tales, the parallels in parables and the lives of those in the old and new testaments match up very closely, with a few holes here and there. The next stop is understand the human "psyche', anima and animus terms Carl Jung has claim to fame. For then we find, those terms are not his at all, but did he knows this? if we read about Jacob Boehme, it was he that could have brought later on the science for electricity and Newton's Law of Gravity, as well as spirals used in meteorology and magnetic fields. For example, the list goes on and one.: The word "souls" (psuchás, plural of psuché) also requires explanation, as the Greek word is far too complex in meaning to define facilely as a person's immortal essence, as most Catholics and Protestants are wont to do. Its basic meaning is "breath," and is thus equivalent to the Hebrew nephesh and Latin anima (as in English "animal" and "animate"). One of its uses is as the New Testament version of what Genesis 2:7 calls "the breath of life," that is, the vital force that makes a body live: "And the LORD God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living being [nephesh]." Luke 12:20 and Acts 20:10 use psuché in this manner.

From this basic meaning derives its extensions: as "life" (see Matthew 6:25; John 10:11; Philippians 2:30; Revelation 12:11) and "living being" (see I Corinthians 15:45; Revelation 16:3). In addition, psuché can refer to the seat of emotion, will, and desire, whereas we would use the terms "heart," "mind," "personality," or "being" today (see Luke 1:46; Acts 14:2, 22; Hebrews 6:19; II Peter 2:14). In a similar sense, it can also identify man's moral and spiritual life (see Hebrews 13:17; I Peter 1:22; 2:11, 25; 4:19; III John 2).

bockshiner profile image

bockshiner 2 hours ago

Interesting hub. "God helps those who help themselves" is the one that bothers me when I hear it because it is contrary to the actually bible teaching. And I always thought "cleanliness is godliness" was a Smashing Pumpkins quote. :)

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working